Ashley for keyboards? Yay or Nay?

Im diggin her work for Abigail Williams, and if she truly does her own writing for her songs then hell yea let her join Cradle. Either her or the Mark dude who did the work for Godspeed. I think letting Ashley in the band will give them a fresh young mind into the mold.

What you people think?

Views: 175

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Jimmy on June 26, 2009 at 19:06
Then why the complaining in the first place. Start your own freakin band if you can do it better
Let's see if you like the comments then...
You're nagging about a new band member who happens to look good and you've never heard or seen her live... Now that's what I call weak

Lady Sinister said:
haha I like Cradle fine...I'm not gonna go psycho over Martin leaving....He obviously doesnt care for Cradle anyways...
:/ some ppl like Ashley, some ppl dont, both sides just have to accept that she's with CoF now, for whatever reason.
As long as i dont start hearong complaints of her live, i dont really mind her on Cradle all that much
DarknessIncarnate said:
Well he's gone now,so just accept it.

if you don't like cradle now,you don't have to listen to them.

Lady Sinister said:
A) not that I would want to
B) whatever.
C) and ha! Real talent was Martin Powell.

DarknessIncarnate said:
What do you know about real talent? I bet you haven't heard anything that Ashley has produced,and you keep insulting her,now you're just being rude.
Who cares what she looks like? seriously,Can't someone play good,and just happen to have good looks?

F*ck. Leave her alone,you don't run Cradle of Filth.

Lady Sinister said:
haha That CoF would rather employ a pretty dumbass than REAL talent...
Face it, thats all either of those 2 women are by many ppls opinions DarknessIncarnate said:
what are you saying by that?

and her name is Ashley...

Scott Milliorn said:
OK, I think Rosie writes great music, and Abigail doesn't. You think the opposite. Cool. Still cant dispute the sex factor over TALENT with either of them.
Permalink Reply by Cassandra on June 26, 2009 at 22:03
Ashley plays the piano beautifully, but her voice is - ehhhmehhh. She needs to work on it.

I thought Rosie was alright.

I wish Sarah would come back, though :|

Seeing Martin on keys again would be nice too :]
Permalink Reply by Jimmy on June 26, 2009 at 23:19
I don't see what you find wrong in her singing.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5aTdikdC2Jo

To me she seems to sing just fine. Like I said before, freakin goosebumps...

Cassandra said:
Ashley plays the piano beautifully, but her voice is - ehhhmehhh. She needs to work on it.

I thought Rosie was alright.

I wish Sarah would come back, though :|

Seeing Martin on keys again would be nice too :]
Permalink Reply by Phalanx Titan on June 27, 2009 at 0:36
Keyboard-wise I don't mind Ashley. However, her vocals just seem...out of place...

I must preferred Sarah's more operatic-style vocals. They fitted much better into CoF's music.
Permalink Reply by Phalanx Titan on June 28, 2009 at 0:08
I agree that some of the comments towards Ashley are rather harsh, considering she is a perfectly capable and talented keyboard-player. I admit, it might take me a while to get used to her vocal style, though.

Martin Curtis-Powell said:
Ashley is an exceptionally gifted musician and pianist. I can think of no better person to be a part of COF's live shows. Having both met her and heard the proficiency of her playing I'm saddened by the childish attitudes on display here. I understand that some of you are technically still children but such vitriol towards someone you've neither met nor heard properly is, for my part, entirely bemusing and unnecessary.

Martin. Ex-COF.
Permalink Reply by Inhuman Affliction on June 28, 2009 at 0:28
People don't like to realize that.

Some of you need to grow up and change the way you think,and that's coming from a 16 year old.

Martin Curtis-Powell said:
Ashley is an exceptionally gifted musician and pianist. I can think of no better person to be a part of COF's live shows. Having both met her and heard the proficiency of her playing I'm saddened by the childish attitudes on display here. I understand that some of you are technically still children but such vitriol towards someone you've neither met nor heard properly is, for my part, entirely bemusing and unnecessary.

Martin. Ex-COF.
Permalink Reply by Cassandra on June 29, 2009 at 7:22
I agree.

Phalanx Titan said:
I agree that some of the comments towards Ashley are rather harsh, considering she is a perfectly capable and talented keyboard-player. I admit, it might take me a while to get used to her vocal style, though.

Martin Curtis-Powell said:
Ashley is an exceptionally gifted musician and pianist. I can think of no better person to be a part of COF's live shows. Having both met her and heard the proficiency of her playing I'm saddened by the childish attitudes on display here. I understand that some of you are technically still children but such vitriol towards someone you've neither met nor heard properly is, for my part, entirely bemusing and unnecessary.

Martin. Ex-COF.
Permalink Reply by Inhuman Affliction on June 30, 2009 at 4:49
I support Ashley all the way.


now...


AYE!!!
Permalink Reply by Inhuman Affliction on June 30, 2009 at 6:17
I believe the topic is Ashley for keyboards.
Permalink Reply by Scott Milliorn on June 30, 2009 at 6:33
Be honest I wouldn't mind Laura mopping the place up a bit, and not letting us on such a lenient leash cause apparently we can't govern ourselves very well sometimes and that goes for all of us on this site. If its the underlining clause in why band members avoid posting then that should encourage everyone to make an effort. Be a lot more fun regardless what are views are to have chats with them.
Permalink Reply by Laura Woodley on June 30, 2009 at 17:58
When I do close threads, I get many messages about "free speech" etc. But I'll gladly close all nonsense topics such as this.

Scott Milliorn said:
Be honest I wouldn't mind Laura mopping the place up a bit, and not letting us on such a lenient leash cause apparently we can't govern ourselves very well sometimes and that goes for all of us on this site. If its the underlining clause in why band members avoid posting then that should encourage everyone to make an effort. Be a lot more fun regardless what are views are to have chats with them.

RSS

© 2013   Created by ADMIN.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service