Ashley for keyboards? Yay or Nay?

Im diggin her work for Abigail Williams, and if she truly does her own writing for her songs then hell yea let her join Cradle. Either her or the Mark dude who did the work for Godspeed. I think letting Ashley in the band will give them a fresh young mind into the mold.

What you people think?

Views: 175

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Mayra Reyes on June 5, 2009 at 0:01
I say yay. She should be part of Cradle Of Filth. Face it everyone...Cradle its not going to be back to their old ways.
Permalink Reply by ben on June 5, 2009 at 1:21
yay
i reckon she is decent
she was awesome live at the 2 sydney shows
Permalink Reply by Sean's Inferno on June 5, 2009 at 1:23
Sure, why not. She's a good keyboardist for sure, and from what I've heard of Abigail Williams (whom she wrote a lot of music for) she can definitely pen a tune.

The only thing which concerns me is the intentions behind her involvement ... on Cradle's part, not necessarily hers. It seems a little bit like they want a "hot chick" to draw more attention to the band - kind of like Sarah Palin in the McCain campaign. But then again, it was probably a similar idea behind recruiting Rosie.

As long as she can play the songs and keep her mouth shut (immensely irritating speaking voice!) then I'm not bothered. However, I hope she won't be doing Sara's vocals for long - hopefully that's just a temporary arrangement.
Permalink Reply by Marshall on June 5, 2009 at 1:29
Ive heard so much about her voice and how its annoying. Anybody know of any videos were shes talking so I can find out. lol
Permalink Reply by Catoues Inferno on June 5, 2009 at 5:00
WTF

I have been gone for 2d? When did Rosie leave?? As far as Ashley. I dont give a shit, Abigail Williams, S U C K'S, ergo, when did Rosie leave?
Permalink Reply by JAMES RIFF WREATH [ lord kaenan} on June 5, 2009 at 6:19
I've heard her play; she's talented...her style more than fits the band[ as I've said many a time before]...I say yay! Hopefully, she'll do some writing!

Always,

Kaenan 1340
Permalink Reply by Sean's Inferno on June 5, 2009 at 11:46
Go on Youtube and type in Abigail Williams interview, there's only a couple of relevant ones. The worst one is about 8 minutes long and features all of them. They're all pretty annoying, but she ... eurgh.

Marshall said:
Ive heard so much about her voice and how its annoying. Anybody know of any videos were shes talking so I can find out. lol
DARK DREAMERPermalink Reply by DARK DREAMER on June 5, 2009 at 12:01
kind of like Sarah Palin in the McCain campaign
Good comparison! ;)

I am really indifferent about this subject. If she can play well then sure, why not?

Sean's Inferno said:
Sure, why not. She's a good keyboardist for sure, and from what I've heard of Abigail Williams (whom she wrote a lot of music for) she can definitely pen a tune.

The only thing which concerns me is the intentions behind her involvement ... on Cradle's part, not necessarily hers. It seems a little bit like they want a "hot chick" to draw more attention to the band - kind of like Sarah Palin in the McCain campaign. But then again, it was probably a similar idea behind recruiting Rosie.

As long as she can play the songs and keep her mouth shut (immensely irritating speaking voice!) then I'm not bothered. However, I hope she won't be doing Sara's vocals for long - hopefully that's just a temporary arrangement.
Permalink Reply by Sardonicus on June 5, 2009 at 14:36
Ashley for keyboards? Why not?
Permalink Reply by deathtrip on June 5, 2009 at 16:43
hell no abigail williams is heavier and darker than cradle it would be a shame if she left for the now comercial cradle. I do agree that she is a dumbass. The band as a whole should shut the fuck up.
Permalink Reply by Sardonicus on June 5, 2009 at 18:34
deathtrip said:
hell no abigail williams is heavier and darker than cradle it would be a shame if she left for the now comercial cradle. I do agree that she is a dumbass. The band as a whole should shut the fuck up.
Sarkasmus... oder?
Permalink Reply by Nadir Tiffauges on June 5, 2009 at 18:55
I always liked how Cradle had that feminine romantic (gothic) side about them..the women on the covers and singing about seraphim and she-wolves..and how Dani and Sarah complimented each other so well..so if you're going to have that gothic romance attitude then I do like seeing women interspersed throughout the band..and if you're going to have a female keyboardist, then might as well make her a smoking hot one.. From what I gather she's pretty good too, right? But I agree, that they need to find someone else to do female vocals..sucks that Sarah is irreplacable as far as myth and lore go..

RSS

© 2013   Created by ADMIN.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service